The whole re-purchasing thing and then when they were explaining their warranty. Carmax & carvana anger me. I think you have to decide for yourself what level of "hassle" it is to address any car issue. I’ve read plenty of CarMax warranty reviews and they seem to be great. How much did they pay me? My wife was on the title with me so I had her sign it and took it with me to pickup. I test drove the car before buying. I didn’t think of bringing to a dealer for inspection within the 7 days, smart!! And they also have a 7 day return policy. (The similar Carvana car would be $1,500 less assuming I could find someone to PM me a referral.). Carmax offered me $9000, and Carvana offered me $10,300. Saved thousands over local dealers. Thanks for the tip! When a used car is sold by a dealership, it is always priced at its retail value. Is Carvana Legit? And here's where Carmax wins in every way: - They extended my return policy to 14 days, no problem. I was selling a 2011 Honda Accord LX with a little under 27,000 miles on it. I cashed the check and used it as part of the down-payment for my new, family-friendly car. Garcia said he sees a path to … By Rebecca Garland That is the premise of both Carvana and CarMax. Carvana: There are two options for Carvana. A coupe offers a winning combination of fun and style, and there are so many great options to choose from. Carmax (64 total cars) the range is 14.8K to 23.9K. When you have a car to sell, sometimes it is easier to let a company write you a check and take it away. The prices may be a little steeper than a dealership due to overhead costs. I was in the market to grab a Lexus GS350 and wanted to trade my 4Runner Pro so I stopped by the CarMax in Westboro. This not saving these tips are how to get half way ripped off not full ripped off. It depends on who you ask. Home Uncategorized carmax vs carvana reddit. Carmax is the nation’s #1 retailer of used cars, selling around 500,000 used cars per year. Since launching in 2012, Carvana has turned the business of buying and selling used vehicles inside out. I test drove the car before buying. ... We've heard from customers that private car sales can take longer than selling a car to CarMax. My assigned customer service rep "Cassandra" put me on hold for over 10 minutes and I finally just hung up. It may just be random based on what car you are looking at. I drove home in a loaner. However, if you sell your car to a dealer like Carmax or Carvana or trade it in on another vehicle, you will receive its wholesale value, which is … ... Roadster, Carvana, Vroom, and CarMax. When comparing CarMax vs Carvana vs Vroom sales models, CarMax is the closest to a regular car dealership, having multiple locations throughout the country. The platform allows consumers to choose a vehicle after inspecting it with the help of the company’s proprietary 360-degree vehicle imaging technology. Carvana: You can submit your car details for re-appraisal in case the 7-day period expires. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. The woman on the phone said, "If you had kept the car and fixed it under our warranty, that would be a different story. I really think they don't actually do an inspection. You'd think that out of 64 cars on Carmax at least one would be in better shape (and therefore more expensive) than the 16 on Carvana. CarMax is the oldest of the three companies, having been founded in the 1990s. I've been very unlucky, lol. Both sell used cars, but both also buy used cars independently of sales. I've bought and sold a number of cars in my life so I didn't give it much thought. I still have the manufacture’s warranty which is reassuring. Plus a delivery fee. Im angered. SELLING USED CARS. Carvana offers a 100-day warranty on all its cars. However CarMax does have a large inventory to choose from. The biggest difference between CarMax and Carvana is that CarMax has physical lots spread out across the country. Carvana warranty vs CarMax warranty. The person picking up asked me if I still wanted to buy the car after they fixed it. Among the Carvana reviews shared on Reddit, one customer explained his experience with the extended warranty. Carmax Versus Carvana Who Should You Sell Your Car To? I've done it a few times, and it always brings out the freaks and charlatans. I wasn't told one thing by an associate, just to have another associate say that's not correct. A place for Carvana reviews, experiences, complaints, and discussion. We like that all … Hello and welcome to Reddit! A similar car at the local dealerships around here would have cost at least a few thousand more. First let’s start with the better one in my opinion and that’s carvana. I have found the opposite to be true, the cheaper deals seem to be on CarMax. CarMax Vs. Carvana - Vehicle Selection Comparison When examining the selection of vehicles at Carvana and CarMax, the makeup of each retailer is similar. They grabbed my Pro and started the assessment process while the sales guy and I went over what I was looking for. I didn’t have to wait long, and I got what I thought was a fair price for my car. selling car to carmax reddit. CarMax offered me $21,000 and they would not match my Carvana offer (See my CarMax offer below) I waited the entire 7-day window and decided that selling my truck to Carvana was super easy and continued with the process; The Appraisal and Offer I Received From CarMax After You Decide To Sell Your Car To Carvana ", I said, "You want me to keep a broken car past its 7 day return policy on a hope that it could be fixed under warranty??" Otherwise, you'll need to wait three days before posting. Taking cues from CarMax, Carvana offers a no-pressure, no-haggle way to buy and sell cars — and does it almost entirely online. Subreddit for carvana.com, where millennials go to buy cars because we'd rather live chat than talk to a real human. Carvana vs. Vroom vs. CarMax comparison Carvana, Vroom and CarMax offer similar inventory selections at comparable prices. Across r/Cars and r/usedcarsales, sellers agree that you can get thousands more from an online vendor than from CarMax. Carvana is the best online car buying site for … tech-savvy, decisive people who are comfortable acting as the point person for their car transaction. Subreddit for carvana.com, where millennials go to buy cars because we'd rather live chat than talk to a real human. CarMax Vs KBB Instant Cash Offer – Is CarMax better than a dealer? If I return this car, because of my bad luck, I might buy a new vehicle, like a 2020 Corolla. Is there any difference between the amount of repair/refurbishment that goes on between the two companies? CarMax has about 50,000 vehicles compared to Carvana’s inventory of about 15,000. CarMax vs. Carvana. I had a similar experience with CarMax. - I never had to call anyone or set up paperwork or do anything except provide my info and wait at the counter. Someone could experience the same story but with the titles of the companies reversed. Unlike taking your car to CarMax to have it evaluated or appraised, Carvana gives you the convenience of having your car appraised online. Carvana Co. and CarMax Inc. are two of the world’s leading used-car retailers.CVNA is primarily an e-commerce platform for buying and selling used cars. It’s the largest used car retailer in the U.S. and is a Fortune 500 company. Vroom Vs Carvana – The Background Stories Credit: Vroom via Facebook Vroom. Looked at other dealerships. There are several to chose from, including Edmunds’ True Market Value, NADA Price Guide, and Kelley Blue Book.The prices for most used cars can be found in these guides, but each calculates them a bit differently, so the value for the same car … You can bring your car to one of their offices/ vending machines or you can choose for them to come … Also, unlike Carmax or Carvana, dealers are open to negotiation, and are often under pressure to move inventory and give you a deal. The car had around 19,500 miles, not normal at all. That is the premise of both Carvana and CarMax. Less than 24hrs after buying the car, the check engine light came on. One of the Carvana reviews we ran across on Reddit said they found it very convenient to handle the car selling process online rather than having to meet people coming to their home to see the car. (The dealer would take one week to even look at the vehicle.). Determining Your Car’s Value. This is America and im never buying from Carmax &Carvana. For me, the dealer that did my inspection within the 7 day period handled the issue quickly and effectively. Now comes the fun part. The truth hurts. That means that you can shop local inventory in person and even test drive cars. Would I sell to them again? ... CarMax is selling a 2016 Toyota Highlander XLE with 26,000 miles for a no-haggle ... CarMax … Carmax customer service was also excellent, on par with Carvana, but the difference is that I got to meet them in person. Ultimately, the best guide to CarMax vs Carvana selling is reading the CarMax and Carvana reviews. Just wanted to share my experiences a little Incase anyone was skeptical about selling. With the advent of home-delivery car-buying services like Carvana and Vroom, it’s easy to get tempted into going with one those, but can still be confusing. Btw if you decide to go with Carvana as of right now I have one code left I could send you! Taking cues from CarMax, Carvana offers … You can browse cars online, buy your car without haggling and then it will be delivered. For example, Lexus CT200h, range on Carvana (16 total cars) is 18.8K - 25.5K. Then she told me, "This is a new car! Carmax vs Carvana Interview Answers. So I bought a 2017 Chevy Volt Premier with 36k from Carmax. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article. So recently I decided to sell my 2014 corvette and my parents 2018 rav 4. But if you like the idea of selling your car without having to participate, CarMax is a better option. Very happy with my decision. Carmax Versus Carvana Who Should I Sell My Car To? I’m looking at a German vehicle so definitely want an extended warranty. I purchased the MaxCare plan, which I really like, because if I have a problem, I drive it in to the service center and talk to a human being. And of course, she's right. I think Carvana is more for people like me, who don't mind some scratches and chips for $1500 savings. CarMax sold 447,491 wholesale units in 2019 and Carvana sold 15,125 in 2018. Tweet. Looked at the CarFax on the vehicle and safety ratings: Looked at the car with both dealers and did research on Carvana as it is a new business model. It depends on who you ask. Current issues with buying online, you be the judge#vroom #vroomreview CarMax: If you got an appraisal online or from one of their stores, you can sell your car to any CarMax locations with the said written offer. But is one better than the other? Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. The list goes on and on. Below, we compare AutoBuy, CarMax, and We Buy Any Car — from accepted vehicles and how to get a quote to requirements for selling your vehicle and more. It's only two years old!". If this is a comment to a post, you may still private message the original author of this post if you wish to contact them. Carvana is a used car buying company that holds a very unique way of car shopping as it is all online. If having a car in perfect condition is important to you, I would not necessarily recommend going with Carvana. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. I told my mom I might opt for a new car instead. They took care of EVERYTHING for me. Carvana is light years beyond Carmax in… Carvana is light years beyond Carmax in terms of customer service. They said they never, ever do things like this and they wouldn't sell the car until it was shipped back to Arizona, inspected/cleaned, and then made available to the public on the website again. It’s called a shitty hand, and you got it in a royal flush. I've looked at cars at CarMax in the past but it's been years. I said yes, if it was fixed at the dealer and I could get my return policy extended, I would give the car another chance. But vehicles at Carvana and CarMax also have higher quality standards. I was trying to buy a car from Carmax but in the end, just gave up. This happened twice with Carvana. That’s why places like CarMax and regular dealerships still exist. In college, I bought an old Suzuki station wagon for $1600 and it didn't need fixed for two years. Press J to jump to the feed. While I'm sure there are cars there that are scratched up and have some damage, I feel like most people's experience with Carvana is that the cars come with scratches, at the very least. I shopped for a used car with both Carvana and CarMax. One guy said I wouldn't pay a deductible, the next one said, "I've never heard about that.". For example, 2016 Mazda MX-5 may be $23,000 from Carmax or $22,000 from Carvana, but $18,500 from a dealer desperate to get it off the lot to make room for more Chevy trucks. This means you won’t need to leave the comfort of your home or office just to go have your car evaluated. To help you find your ideal coupe, here is a list of the 10 best coupe cars for 2020 shoppers, based on CarMax sales data from September 1, 2019 through February 29, 2020. And they also have a 7 day return policy. I contacted Carvana to see about starting the purchasing process again. Carmax (64 total cars) the range is 14.8K to 23.9K. Wholesale contributes nicely to gross profit at CarMax making up $431 million of the $2,481 million total. When he called Carvana customer service, the customer was told that his car had been refurbished but that the refurbishment was not disclaimed. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. But at a minimum, be sure to negotiate at CarMax, Carvana, etc, when you think about purchasing an extended warranty or other insurance product. We like that all three of their websites are relatively easy to navigate. If you decide to return the car within 7 days, they will set the pickup details and have you refunded the full cost of the vehicle excluded shipping and delivery fees, if any. Contacted Carvana. Negotiate the sale of your vehicle Last but not least, you can always negotiate the selling price of your trade-in (if you’re in a position to sell … ... Carvana Car Selling Process Review: ... Carvana Vs CarMax Vs … Anything that elicits a slightly perceived better experience is hailed as the “holy grail” of the book end on the right. Carvana was very good with communication about the purchase process, but never discussed the trade in process. - How CarMax reacted to Carvana entering Raleigh in 2015 - The offline vs online sales progression - Challenges for CarMax selling vehicles online and through the hybrid model - How to incentivize sales staff between offline and online sales - How CarMax looks at managing both slow and fast moving inventory - CarMax in-store reconditioning efficiency - Advantages Carvana could have over CarMax It's at Carmax being diagnosed now. In other words, it’s the maximum value of the vehicle — it’s best price. FAQs Carvana CarMax; 1. I sold my MK7 GTI to Carvana! I guess the inspection does not cover checking for leaks, it was very very obvious. I also went through the process of selling a vehicle with both … Thanks for tips. The process of buying or selling a car with CarMax and Carvana is remarkably similar. You should buy from Carmax if… You like test-driving lots of cars before you commit (and you should). They said no way they can extend the 7 day period. Their business model requires a constant inflow of used vehicles from various sources, making Carmax the largest used car buyer in the country too. Carmax customer service was also excellent, on par with Carvana, but the difference is that I got to meet them in person. It looks like you have a relatively new account - unfortunately posting has been disabled for accounts less than three days old (this helps prevent false reviews). Dealership stated cannot look at it for a week, really liked the vehicle wand wanted to keep it, but wanted to make sure it was nothing serious. Carvana has disrupted the used car industry since it launched in 2012, and it is apparent that CarMax … I find it very strange that two newly purchased vehicles are needing repairs the very next day. How easy was the sale? So while you could get a good offer today, tomorrow could be a different story. When it comes time to say goodbye to your current set of wheels you have plenty of options; sell to Carvana, sell to CarMax, sell to a private party. CarMax Vs KBB Instant Cash Offer – Is CarMax better than a dealer? Startup Carvana only managed to average $902 per unit. CarMax is the oldest of the three companies, having been founded in the 1990s. Carvana is selling about a quarter as many vehicles as CarMax Inc., the largest used-car dealer in America. CarMax vs. Carvana. For example, Lexus CT200h, range on Carvana (16 total cars) is 18.8K - 25.5K. I bought through both and had a good experience with both but overall liked CarMax more. You can browse cars online, buy … But in any case, I'm thoroughly done with Carvana and any online car buying experience. I thought, well maybe I need a newer car with less miles. They dont check themselves, its up to you to do this. My earlier post about my Carvana car breaking down is here: https://www.reddit.com/r/carvana/comments/cnspe6/car_is_dead_three_hours_after_delivery/. It may just be random based on what car you are looking at. If you're the same as me, Carvana is a good choice. However, CarMax… Selling a car is not fun. But if you like the idea of selling your car without having to participate, CarMax is a better option. In trying to determine whether CarMax or Carvana is the better place to buy or sell a used car, it’s helpful to look at the pluses and minuses of each. Recently, I went through the process of selling my 2017 Volvo S90 to Carvana, and the process was unlike any other car dealership experience I have ever had before. Check out our Carvana vs. CarMax article for an indepth comparison. Some of this is annotated on the 360 view and some of it isn't and isn't even visible. carmax vs carvana reddit. If they do, it's for very limited, cursory things. Carvana.com shows 13,805 and they are growing much faster than CarMax and AutoNation. I was contacted saying the car would be fixed in a week. September 15, 2020 Share. I think, people look for the worst in any given situation, and adhere it to the lefternmost book end as the “bad” “evil” end of the range for their expected experience. I will be buying soon and deciding between similar cars at both. The list goes on and on. Carvana. It was either not done, or the inspector was incompetent. Received positive feedback from other coworkers. CarMax competes against the certified pre-owned used cars offered at traditional franchised used car dealers (i.e. Recently, I went through the process of selling my 2017 Volvo S90 to Carvana, and the process was unlike any other car dealership experience I have ever had before. Carvana is another car buying option, which takes place almost entirely online. Carvana’s revenue growth is much higher (114% average annual revenue growth over the 2017-2019 period vs about 8.9% for CarMax), which explains the higher P/S multiple. Vroom, a New York City-based used car retailer is also an e-commerce company that provides consumers a way to buy, sell and finance cars on the Internet. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Carvana vs. Vroom vs. CarMax comparison Carvana, Vroom and CarMax offer similar inventory selections at comparable prices. The process of buying or selling a car with CarMax and Carvana is remarkably similar. No problem. Pin. Selling a car to CarMax vs Carvana; CarMax and Carvana pros and cons; 1.Carvana or CarMax: Which is Better. I also bought a 2018, 4,000 miles. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns. It's all just my opinion though. Carvana’s revenue growth is much higher (114% average annual revenue growth over the 2017-2019 period vs about 8.9% for CarMax), which explains the higher P/S multiple. You browse the vehicles online, decide to purchase and finance online and then get it delivered to your house. Car returned. With their famous tagline “The way car buying should be”, CarMax has definitely built a reputation as a substantial in the used car buying and selling game. A woman from Carvana just took an Uber over to my house, gave me a check which apparently had been issued yesterday, and drove away in the car. A place for Carvana reviews, experiences, complaints, and discussion. If you're looking to sell your car, you've got options beyond trading in or selling your car privately.